Request a Review
MSR Decode · Contract information · Case 18

ForecastEx gives two different closing dates for its House election markets

Its market records say January 4, 2027. The linked rules point to January 2. Aries shows the later date.

By MSR Decode · Published November 1, 2026 · 5 min read
Contents
  1. 01 · How the two dates arise
  2. 02 · Why the closing time matters
  3. 03 · The earlier date comes from filed rules
  4. 04 · The later date also appears at brokers
  5. What the record leaves unresolved
  6. Supporting records

On November 1, ForecastEx gave two different answers to a basic question about its 2026 House election markets: when does trading end? Its online records said January 4, 2027, while the written rules linked from those records pointed to just before midnight on January 2—a difference of about 39 hours. A customer following the rules link therefore gets a different answer about how long they can try to leave a position.[1,2]

Aries, a broker offering these markets, showed the later closing time. Interactive Brokers (IBKR) also supplied that time in its public rules data. The code behind its market page uses the closing time to decide whether to label the market open or closed.[3,4]

How the two dates arise

These markets let people trade on whether the Democratic Party or the Republican Party will win a House majority in the 2026 election. Each party has its own question, with a Yes and a No contract. The timetable separates three things: when trading stops, when ForecastEx determines the result, and when payment is expected.[1,2,4]

For both House questions, ForecastEx’s online records give January 4 at 3 p.m. Central as the last time to trade. The exchange’s page labels this “Last Trade Time.” Each record also links to a document setting out the rules for that contract.[1]

The document gives a different timetable. Under its normal schedule, ForecastEx determines the result at 7 a.m. Central on January 4 of the year after the election. Trading must end at 11:59:59 p.m. two calendar days earlier. For the 2026 election, that means January 2, 2027.[2]

Here is how those times compare. All are shown in Central time, so time zones do not account for the difference.[1,2,3,4]

Where the deadline appearsWhen trading ends in 2027
ForecastEx’s written rules, using the normal timetable [2]January 2 · 11:59:59 p.m. Central
ForecastEx’s online market records [1]January 4 · 3 p.m. Central
Aries’ House market page [3]January 4 · 3 p.m. Central
IBKR’s public rules data [4]January 4 · 3 p.m. Central

Both House questions; records saved November 1, 2026. The first date is calculated from the written rules. The other three are listed by the exchange or broker. The exact gap is 39 hours and one second.

A customer who wants to leave one of these positions has to make another trade. Aries explains that someone holding Yes exits by buying No for the same question, while someone holding No buys Yes.[8]

A customer needs the closing time to know how long they can try to leave a position. Yet checking the exchange’s market record and then following its rules link produces two different timetables for the same trade.[1,2,8]

The earlier date comes from filed rules

The same trading deadline appears in documents ForecastEx sent to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission on July 31, 2026. The submission says changes to all listed contracts would take effect on August 14. The House rules attached to that filing have the same wording as the six-page document the exchange still links to.[2,5]

ForecastEx’s rulebook says it must publish terms for its contracts and that the contracts are subject to those terms. The earlier date therefore comes from written rules that the exchange itself directs readers to.[1,5,6]

The later date also appears at brokers

IBKR’s public rules data gives January 4 at 3 p.m. Central for all four choices: Yes and No for the Democratic question, and Yes and No for the Republican question. Each record links to the same written rules containing the earlier deadline.[4]

We also checked the published software code for IBKR’s ForecastTrader page. It tells the page to show “Market Open” before the closing time stored in those records and “Market Closed” once that time is reached. It uses the same time for the countdown.[4]

Aries shows the equivalent time as 4 p.m. Eastern on January 4. Its public contract data also gives January 4 as the last trading date for both House questions.[3,7]

Aries warns that leaving a position depends on finding a matching trade and can be affected by operating problems. The written rules also allow early determination of the result and timetable changes if the official source changes its schedule. This comparison uses the normal timetable and the records saved on November 1.[2,8]

Evidence tables, source files and corrections

Supporting records

[1] ForecastEx’s market records

Saved on November 1. The two records are HORC_1126_Democratic and HORC_1126_Republican. Both give January 4, 2027, at 3 p.m. Central as the last trading time and link to the same House rules PDF. The page’s published code labels this time separately from the expected result and payment.

Exchange contract records · House contract page · Published page code

[2] How the earlier date was calculated

Pages 1 and 4 of the House rules give the trading deadline and the normal time for deciding the result. Together they produce January 2, 2027, at 11:59:59 p.m. Central as the trading deadline. The later displayed close is exactly 39 hours and one second afterward. Eight hours of that gap fall after the rules’ normal time for deciding the result. The saved research record includes the full calculation and a digital fingerprint of the PDF.

House terms and conditions

[3] The closing time on Aries’ page

The page saved on November 1 says trading closes on January 4, 2027, at 4 p.m. Eastern. That is 3 p.m. Central. It lists the expected result and payment separately.

Aries House market page

[4] IBKR’s data and market-display code

The public records for all four Yes/No choices give the same closing time: January 4, 2027, at 3 p.m. Central. Two separate sets of saved responses were identical. The published ForecastTrader code, version 0.84.0, uses that time for the open/closed label and countdown. The saved research record identifies the exact records, code passages and separate service used by the order form.

Democratic Yes rules · Democratic No rules · Republican Yes rules · Republican No rules · Current client code · Explanation of the rules data

[5] The rules filed with the regulator

CFTC filing 62300 was submitted on July 31, 2026. It says changes to all listed Forecast Contracts take effect on August 14. The House rules are on pages 1–6 of Part 03. Their wording matches the currently linked PDF when differences in spacing are removed.

Submission and effective date · Clean House terms

[6] What ForecastEx’s rulebook says

The September 22, 2026 rulebook covers the duty to publish contract terms and the requirement that contracts follow them: Rules 311(d), 401(d) and 602(e). Rules 402 and 413–415 cover trading schedules and changes. None of the passages reviewed explicitly explains which of the conflicting House dates takes priority.

ForecastEx Rulebook

[7] Aries’ contract data

Both House records give January 4 as the last trading date. Two copies retrieved on November 1 without signing in were identical; the records give October 31 as their last refresh date. This source is used for the date. The Eastern closing time was checked separately on Aries’ market page. The saved research record includes the original values and the file’s digital fingerprint.

Aries’ House contract records · Explanation of Aries’ contract data

[8] How customers leave a position

Aries’ disclosure explains buying the opposite answer to exit a position. It identifies Advantage Futures as the firm carrying customers’ accounts and warns about limits caused by available trades or operating problems. ForecastEx Rule 604 explains how the opposite positions are cancelled and how payment follows. Buying the opposite contract and receiving the resulting payment are separate steps.

Aries event-contract disclosure · Rulebook and rules for closing positions

[9] What we checked and saved

The research record lists the contracts, saved dates, calculations, code references and file fingerprints used to identify our copies. We reviewed nine later filings about contract terms, the collected member notices and descriptions of 36 rule filings since August 14. We read six potentially relevant rule submissions and the full election-retainer program terms. Checks of past trades found no trade after the relevant cutoff that settled the question. These checks do not cover every possible communication. We did not sign into an account, preview or place an order, or contact the companies.

The IBKR code tells us what the page is designed to show. It does not tell us whether a customer’s trade would go through. The order form uses a separate service to check rules for that customer; we did not access its answer for these House markets. Nor does IBKR’s software establish how Aries or Advantage Futures, the firm carrying Aries customers’ accounts, would handle a trade. We did not submit or preview an order.[4,8,9]

The January 4 date could come from shared data rather than separate checks by each company. This comparison uses the normal timetable, which permits early determination and schedule changes under the written rules.

Retained research record · CFTC product-terms filing index

Ask MSR to investigate

Tell us which wallet, market, payout or profit claim you want checked. MSR accepts commissioned investigations using the evidence standards shown in this report.

Request a Review →

← Back to Case Work